implied sexism

[novapsyche]

Double Standard -- Wash Post article

On paper, Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor resembles one of her would-be colleagues on the high court: Princeton undergrad, Yale Law School, an editor on the Yale Law Journal, experience as a prosecutor and years of service on the federal bench.

Yet Judge Sotomayor, President Obama's pick to replace retiring Justice David H. Souter, is not being compared by some conservatives to Princeton/Yale alum Samuel A. Alito Jr., widely acclaimed as smart and qualified when he was nominated. Instead, they are trying to peg her as "President Obama's Harriet Miers," after the nominee of President George W. Bush who took herself out of contention as conservatives savaged her reputation and raised doubts about whether she was smart enough for the job.

Why is that?

[...] Karl Rove implicitly questioned Judge Sotomayor's intelligence, saying in an interview with PBS host Charlie Rose that "I know lots of stupid people who went to Ivy League schools." No doubt, but would Mr. Rove have said the same thing in connection with Justice Alito?

Comments

[pstscrpt.livejournal.com]

Alito is qualified except that he doesn't believe in Marbury v. Madison, which has effectively been a major part of the constitution for most of our country's history, and pretty much says what the Supreme Court is for.

Would we call a well-studied lawyer who regularly wears "Fuck this court" shirts to trials qualified?

[novapsyche.livejournal.com]

Why would a Supreme Court Justice disagree with Marbury? I just don't understand.

[pstscrpt.livejournal.com]

He's made various statements about the right of the people to have their collective will expressed. The only case I can think of where he's actually voted to overturn a law on constitutional grounds is the D.C. handgun case.

The Republican Party in general seems to be opposed to Marbury with their "activist judges" crap, but Renquist, Scalia, Thomas and especially Roberts haven't been nearly as explicit about it as Alito has been.

[davidfcooper.livejournal.com]

Karl Rove implicitly questioned Judge Sotomayor's intelligence, saying in an interview with PBS host Charlie Rose that "I know lots of stupid people who went to Ivy League schools."

Did Rove have his former boss in mind when he said that?